There are few more soothing comfort foods than old-fashioned shredded chicken sandwiches. The best sandwiches I have ever had! The Amish Way Cookbook More info. Cook meat in salt water until it is tender. It’s a perfect cool winter day for some comfort food. West Unity, Ohio (up in the northeast corner about halfway between Fort Wayne, Indiana and Toledo, Ohio) here, GO HILLTOP! https://keystonemeats.com/recipes/shredded-chicken-sandwiches Our Mom took the sandwiches away, took out all the skin, then we enjoyed our sandwiches. I don’t remember these sandwiches, most likely because I was a VERY picky eater!! This was the shinning moment in an otherwise lackluster season. . Hot Shredded Chicken with cream of chicken/mushroom, spices and chicken flavored stuffing. Their amazing and so close to Maxie’s! Remove meat from broth; add minced onion and, parsley to broth. Mix all ingredients together. Thanks for sharing this recipe. I grew up in Cass County, Indiana. https://www.recipesthatcrock.com/crock-pot-creamed-chicken-sandwich I know and have worked with Gribbles from GH, but time has taken their names from my memory. Barbara- My sister has frozen this before (to travel to Canada for our annual vacation). BTW- love Zaycon meats and will be using their chicken for the party!! I chose yours because you mentioned Ohio. I was looking for a recipe that mimicked the hot shredded chicken sandwiches that Max’s drive in North Canton served. WOW! For some reason it just makes me smile every time someone mentions eating this at a DQ! I’ve got to try that next time. I have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken to make. Thanks, again! We used Stove Top stuffing mix with cream of chicken, and the broth from roasting the turkey. Made in Tiffin Ohio! We will be making it again and again. Thanks for stopping by to share your story with this recipe! I am from Perrysburg, now living in Texas. When the cooker cools down, I’ll strain all the liquid off through a permanent coffee filter though any micro-mesh will work though. If needed, use a good quality chicken stock to make gravy. I have not heard of that canned chicken, will have to look for it. I grew up in Bellville and always got these at the A & W Root Beer drive in! No one has mentioned the hot chicken sandwiches at the Lions tent-Loudonville Free St Fair? Thank you, thank you, thank you! Deanna- yes it does freeze well! She makes it for all of the family parties. 2. But if you are worried about it, you can always add in some of the soup/broth from the start. Cover and cook for 20 minutes, adding more water if needed. Crock Pot Hot Cheesy Chicken Sandwiches is the perfect leftover chicken or rotisserie chicken crock pot recipe.. Great tip! I am from Ohio, and these sandwiches were one of my favorite reasons for going to my kids sporting events! Pull chicken out of pot and shred. p.s. Difference being if we didn’t use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken, not just the breast. DeLoris. You can add bread crumbs or Ritz crackers to thicken if too runny or make more gravy if too stiff. Beat butter until fluffy. BBQ Pulled Chicken Sandwiches. I grew up in Ada, Ohio. I grew up in Ohio and my grandma made these in the 60’s and 70’s. Add parsley and chicken. I think potato chips are my next try as filler. I am a Findlay girl, now living in Indiana. Throw some Conns potato chips on the plate with the sandwich and you got a group of happy ppl. Nothing else! Shredded chicken sandwiches are a leftover from the days when everyone had chickens and you didn't butcher them until they quit laying eggs. I decided to do a mix of breadcrumbs and a stockpile pantry staple croutons. To me all you taste is stuffing. I’m from Vaughnsville now living in Fl. Roll out paper thin and cut into 1-inch squares. Combine potatoes and 1/2 cup of cheese, spread over beef mixture. I use to be Patches on the Patches and Pockets show so traveled all over Ohio..Thanks. Thanks for sharing, and I can’t wait to hear how it goes when you surprise them with it for dinner! Making this weekend to serve with chilli. I’m from Piqua, Ohio and I used to have to wait for our local BK rootbeer stand to open so I could enjoy a shredded chicken sandwich. Here is a very quick and easy recipe for shredded chicken sandwiches. I’ve never tried with bread crumbs or croutons so might have to give it a try. Left Ohio in 1966 after college ONU. Cream of chicken soup: I prefer Cream of Chicken Soup with Herbs as it gives the dish some extra flavor but regular cream of chicken soup or cream of mushroom soup can be used instead. This was spectacular! Connie- Updated: Aug 28, 2020 by Kevin Williams | Leave a Comment. I will be one happy lady tonight when I eat these for after all of these years. See more ideas about Recipes, Cooking recipes, Food. This is important when you live in FL and it is 9 million degrees outside!! Needless to say…..I appreciate whoever came up with the Mansfield FB and love it when there is a new posting. 1. . I think the croutons give it a nice texture and added flavor. Rebecca- great question! And no not from Ohio, I love the “Thanksgiving” twist on yours. I’ve spent almost three decades exploring Amish settlements and kitchens from Maine to Montana and almost everywhere in between. Nothing but shredded chicken sandwiches and cracklins say Ohio more to me. 1. I love this hot sticky weather we are having. I finally asked his mom and found several recipes on pinterest. Over the years it appears shredded chicken is more common north of I-70 than south…100% of people in my hometown area of Lima know what this is…maybe 50% in the Columbus area….maybe 10% in Cincinnati. It is very common to see these sandwiches served at the concessions for sporting events as well as local ice cream stands, I had no idea this is a regional treat. I shred them add BBQ sauce and some chopped onions, heat them and serve them on onion rolls. He’s a happy Buckeye! There was a meal at the church afterward with so much delicious food, including a big pile of buns and a big dish of the chicken mix. 36 oz Canned chunk chicken… Can’t find a good one here in North West Ohio anywhere. I love the drink pairing, root beer float- Perfect! It was okay but still remains on my not so favorite list. I use corn flakes, I crush them before adding them them. Born and raised in small town Ohio – Millersburg to be exact. Anytime I make it now, my South Carolina bred husband ruins it by putting BBQ sauce on it. I love to hear everyone’s stories on this recipe! Oatmeal, huh. Moved to Houston in 1995. The party isn’t until the end of April and the food needs to travel 7 hours to get there. We always have made it with the cream soup…mushroom or chicken and stove top stuffing breadcrumb mix. I’ll occasionally throw in stories of my travels, journalism adventures (I’m a Pulitzer prize-nominated journalist), fascination with grocery stores and Kmarts, and much more! Yum! Easy pulled chicken sandwiches topped with a sweet and tangy cabbage slaw. https://missiontosave.com/ohio-sloppy-chicken-sandwich-crockpot-recipe 27 Easy Frugal Meals for Families - The Frugal Foot Doc. Love these, I am from Dover, OH (near Canton and next to New Phila). Hope that helps. Brice, Thanks so much for sharing your memories and info on this iconic recipe! I live in North Carolina now. I grew up in Ohio as well. Delicious!!! We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. My daughters favorite meal!! I sometimes will soften some celery and onion in butter and add to this recipe. I was Merlyn’s daughter. https://www.cleverlysimple.com/crockpot-hot-shredded-chicken-sandwich-recipe I decided to google it recently and found that is is a very regional recipe… meaning if you aren’t from Ohio- you probably have never heard of this recipe (let alone eaten it). Jones Potato Chip factory. I have great summer memories that involved eating shredded chicken sandwiches :). This post may contain affiliate links. YES KW! Good tip on the thighs. Deb thanks for rating my recipe! Simply the best, I’m so excited to try this recipe. We use to get the chicken sammich from the A & W in Ashland. Wagner's IGA Village Market 200 S. Main Street Fort Loramie, OH 45865 937/420-3537: Thanks to Kyle S. for the tip. I am sure all of us have had one of those days. This traditional Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe is a classic. I live in New York now, and the last time I had these sandwiches was when I went back to OH for my dad’s funeral about five years ago. and some farmers markets etc will sell the. I remember my sisters and I watching Patches and Pockets! One regional food native to the farmlands of Ohio is the Ohio Shredded Chicken sandwich – also called the sloppy chicken or hot pressed chicken sandwich. Combine beef, onions, beans, salt, sugar, and barbecue sauce. or the original Route 30 by Central Catholic HS? I’ve done this in the past and it is the perfect start to chicken & noodles! I have lived North of the Ohio border for 30 years. My mother used to crush up bags of oyster crackers to mix in, and would add a dollop of sour cream for a little added zip and creaminess. Everyone keeps mentioning the chips- I think I have to try that one next time too! There is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell. I crush a sleeve of buttery townhouse crackers add that to the chicken, add cream of chicken soup and a teaspoon of poultry seasoning. for? (and it’s ok if you aren’t from Ohio! We’ve made this for years…..using plain potato chips…delicious!!! but he’d say no. Thanks Mary! I’m frugal, but yikes I wouldn’t want to bite into the skin either! Anyone know? Fixed very similar, but I use Peppridge Farms Herb stiffing mix instead of crackers. Also another Ohio thing, making chicken & noodles, mashed potatoes, and corn! We lived in Findlay. No one ever knows what I’m talking about when I say I miss these yummy sandwiches!! It really is great family, comfort food. I have relatives from GH IM FROM Vaughnsville in Putnam Co. left after college in 1962, but the chicken sandwiches served at church suppers are one of my best memories. Directions. Thanks for sharing. I am from Fostoria, OH- Seneca Co. They are in our family cookbook. From Mansfield also. Nutritional Info. Wait. Pick the chicken (let it cool a bit so you don’t burn your hands) being careful to remove all bones and skin. To make dough, beat egg and add milk. Thank you for this recipe. Keep broth boiling while adding dough squares in order to keep them from packing together. I love to see all the variations on this classic! You wouldn’t believe some of the stuff they can come up with down here when you ask for shredded chicken sandwiches. Im originally from Nee Phila!!! Yay a Columbus neighbor! I’m using Turkey for mine and also use stuffing mix. Thanks for the recipe! These are creamy and delicious shredded chicken sandwiches. I have not used canned chicken, however I use precooked whole chickens that you buy at Sam's or Costco. Crush the Ritz crackers into crumbs. I have loved hearing where you all have found this hot chicken sandwich recipe over the years; from the concession stand to being on the menu as the Dairy Queen shredded chicken sandwich (read all the comments below and add yours!) This recipe consists of shredded chicken cooked in a creamy sauce and served on a toasted bun. I grew up in Ohio and this was one of my very favorite foods that I can never get anywhere else. 217 pages, 5-1/2" x 8-1/2", comb bound, illustrated. I grew up near Zanesville and remember these from church potlucks and family get-togethers. . Thanks for sharing your connection to this recipe! You can also use the mixture as a filling for chicken enchiladas or as a potato chip dip. and/or Buy: The Amish families in the Walnut Creek Valley in Holmes County, Ohio share their "tastes" with you. I will have to stop soon. They started with chickens that would be cooked down until the meat fell apart. a vegan version would be quite interesting. I didn’t realize that pulled chicken is totally a Buckeye tradition!!! One that uses canned chicken and that is Recipe for Shredded Chicken Sandwiches. Will try making it with rotisserie chicken. Add flour to make a stiff dough. By: Mary Hoover / Updated on: November 9, 2020 / This post may contain affiliate links, disclosure policy. Oh no BBQ! Step 1 Place the chicken in a large pot and cover it with water. 2 LG can of cooked chicken (48oz each) 3 cans of cream of chicken (10 1/2oz each) and Ritz crackers for the buttery flavor that is very distinct. Tex-Mex has its influence for sure. The canned chicken was already thickened; if you used your own whole chicken you needed to thicken it with something so lots of people used Town House or Ritz crackers or just a little flour. Yay! Thank you for posting this recipe. I am now in Florida and sometimes get a craving for these. Create a Recipe Makeover . And I love all the comments too! I never knew DQ had these on the menu! Anyone have it? I bet it has more flavor! Great memories of eating Ohio chicken sandwiches at church suppers. Salads and Sandwiches «︎ Back to Recipes. They are simply delicious! 2-3 hours just chicken, 2-3 hrs with soup and bread crumbs/chips/crackers, 1 after shredding. Sure, I don’t see why not. Keep broth boiling while adding dough squares in order to keep them from packing together. This points back to the depression era where they would have been unavailable. I grew up in Knox County, Ohio and you can find these sandwiches at almost every concession stand, especially during a baseball game! Stir chicken until all pieces appear to be shredded. Yes, perfect for cool/cold days. Whenever they we on the menu, my sisters and I were very excited. Mom saved the day, however, when she created a reasonable facsimile. Yum! My uncle had a deli Ohio. Dena- I’d say the 3 chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches (depending on how generous the server is). I’m a Cincinnatian and this yummy sandwich was at every church potluck growing up. We have not seen any place in Florida that serves these sandwiches. That’s the only way I make it now. Always made without the crumbs but will try it this time. We always have some in the freezer for quick meals… Best served with potato chips and a root beer float. I aleays had Rootschicken in stock. Add a couple tablespoons of sour cream and stir in, though cream cheese would also work and be thicker. The stuffing adds wonderful flavor! Learning to do it from scratch is insurance that I’ll never lose my favorite chicken sandwich. I lived in Tiffin until my family moved when I was in the 6th Grade. Add the salt and pepper. . Thanks for sharing! Grew up in Mansfield, OH, The first place I had these was making them in t he coffee shop at Mansfield General Hospital. . Lots of families have their own secret shredded chicken recipes. Chicken: I use crockpot shredded chicken for casserole recipes but rotisserie chicken, canned chicken, leftover chicken, or any other pre-cooked chicken work also. Hello Mary, Oh my gosh, I remember eating these sandwiches at my Grandma’s. I just started using the mixer hack to shred the chicken- game changer! I am a Buckeye living in Willis, Texas. Trying to find just 5 recipes to share is always a challenge. I followed your recipe cooking in just chicken broth, seasoned salt and garlic powder. So glad I can freeze this! Learn how your comment data is processed. Pour mixture into large saucepan. I’m from Mansfield,Ohio and don’t remember any crackers or chips in this recipe. Chic-fil-A has spoiled us into thinking that all chicken sandwiches … Thanks for stopping by to share your “shredded chicken” story! Some Dairy Queen restaurants serve them . 2 1/2 cups of shredded chicken; large pot of chicken broth or stock; Instructions . I made this recipe for the Mansfield High Soccer concessions for a few years. Well, then I went vegan… I miss these sandwiches, so I am veganizing your recipe. Place a cutting board on top of the sandwich, and then place a heavy weight on the cutting board (helps … They were so good! I made these chicken sandwiches for our Christmas eve get together. Question for you. And trying turkey would be great with Thanksgiving deals/leftovers. I’ve mostly used the chicken stuffing; but have replaced it with turkey stuffing for thanksgiving parties.. . Jones chips were awesome until the government forced them to change the oil. Hope that helps. Our Bettsville basketball boosters used to roast turkey, debone it and make shredded turkey sandwiches for the basketball teams after games. Still make these and they are good deep fried too! You can buy shredded chicken in the deli department for about $4.50/pound (2011). Shelly- thanks so much for stopping by to comment. Try the healthy BBQ pulled chicken on a bun, in lettuce wraps, on salads and more. I’ve made them different ways but stick to cream of chicken soup, Panko, Johnny’s seasoned salt, black pepper and a bit of horseradish, Oh my hubs would love the addition of the horseradish. Chicken Spagetti From Plain Wisdom: An Invitation into An Amish Home and the Hearts of Two Women. Tap the stars to rate or give a rating the comments section below. Yes! INGREDIENTS. See my privacy policy for details. Another good reason for learning to make it from scratch is god-forbid if we ever find ourselves without ritz crackers or Jones’ chips or Stove-Top stuffing or anything else manufactured. Thanks for sharing your recipe. And Chinese auctions I have never heard of… hmm…. But isn’t is interesting how food can comfort the soul. Somewhere along the line, this was changes and some started adding boxed chicken stuffing. I plan to shock ’em all and serve them up your recipe some evening for dinner. Now we live in Tennessee and I was happy to be reminded of this recipe- we live it and have made t for family gatherings lately. I tried recreating them many times, years ago to no avail. Making for Superbowl….go Falcons!! seasoned bread crumbs. You’re welcome, You’re welcome, You’re welcome! Elizabeth Hall. Lots of recipes but they nearly all the same. Mix back into crockpot, cook another hour. If you try it, let me know how it turns out! I would love to find the recipe for Maidrites. You want the texture to be solid, you need it to hold its shape in a hamburger bun but to give when you bite into it. Perfect! Thanks! These are creamy and delicious shredded chicken sandwiches. I’m hoping this is the recipe that I remember from Friday night football games and chinese auctions (are these an ohio thing too)? I just want to add that this isn’t familiar to all Ohioans. Although I think my husband would revolt if I used canned meat (he say he can taste the difference) I also use any leftovers to make creamy chicken soup with it. Such a fitting name. To make dough, beat egg and add milk. Gerber’s Amish Farm Chicken, cooked & shredded. I was born and raised in Coshocton, Ohio from the late 1940’s to mid 60’s. I use stovetop stuffng instead of crackers or chips! The internet and I find someone from home….Imagine….. Usually add the cream of chicken soup and also some chicken stock / base. I grew up in Upper Sandusky, OH – Wyandot County (NO, not Cedar Point) and I loved the Dairy Snack’s and Mike’s shredded chicken sandwiches. My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe for years (usually for the big family summer vacay trip)! These where the staple at them with a bowl of homemade ice cream. It can really be made in less than 1/2 he to be honest. I’m a western NY gal, my first time making this..,6 chicken breasts spent overnight in crockpot on low with chicken stock, perfect for shredding 6 hours later..now happily in cream of chicken soup and stuffing mix..off to church event today…thinking if I want any for myself, I’d best leave a bowl home! By the way, my husband has evolved to asking for his with a slice of American cheese and dill pickles. ). Everyone keeps talking about the chips! Do you have some leftovers from this classic meal? To taste. I live in the Toledo area…My absolute favorite sandwich!!! Lots of black pepper and I sliced tomatoes to go on the top – one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in ages. I have fond memories of these sandwiches growing up in Ohio. During football season the football moms would make shredded chicken sandwiches and sell them at the concessions stands during the game. I’m from Mansfield, too and everyone I know that makes these sandwiches says no to the crackers or chips. My grandmother used to make shredded chicken quite often but I never really cared for hers. I’m originally from Tiffin, Ohio, in Seneca County, where the shredded chicken sandwich remains a staple. « Throwback Thursday: Check Out These Chains Closing.... 3 /4 cups shredded cheddar cheese, divided. Definitely on our rotation now. I really had no idea this was an Ohio thing, had it all my life so assumed everyone eats it. I used to go to Mount Vernon and Mansfield growing up. THANK YOU SO MUCH! Start Here to Learn How to Save Money With Coupons, can substitute can of chicken broth - just add a little more breadcrumbs, seasoned breadcrumbs, saltine crackers, croutons or mix, dash of seasoned salt and garlic powder to taste, chicken, sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe. To taste. The Circleville, OH DQ also has these on the menu so I can always go on my lunch break and get one. Heat and let cook to mix flavors. I grew up in Knox too! I’m thinking it would get crusty and stick to the crockpot. It’s exactly what I’ve been looking for. thanks. Thanks. I mean comfort food meal ended with ice cream- what could be better!?! Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. We always used potato chips and some bread. I have been making this recipe for a few years now, and it is always the first recipe I pull out when I know the day is going to be long and crazy. Your email address will not be published. And if you try a new “filler” ingredient- let us know which one. I use mine for the more universal Chicken Noodle Soup (see link to recipe above). And I especially love you calling it a “fellowship dish”. Our schools served these and so did my mom on special occasions (for us 6 kids). Perhaps the best part of this meal is that these sandwiches … Who would have guessed!? One of the easiest and best comfort foods. These sandwiches are very popular in this area (Ohio). Make broth and boil sliced carrots and green beans until soft. Return to skillet; stir to coat … Seems like the ice cream shops are a popular place to serve these. INGREDIENTS 1 50-ounce can of shredded chicken 1 tube Ritz crackers (around 30) 1 can cream of chicken soup Hamburger buns DIRECTIONS Open the canned chicken and skim off the fat from the top. Save this recipe for Slow Cooker Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches for all your festive fall gatherings. It is not a chicken sloppy joe recipe- they are shredded chicken sandwiches without a tomato/barbecue base. So when you cook the chicken in a crockpot you don’t need to add any liquid to it for the first couple of hours? Serve on good quality buns. I used to date a guy from alvada/new riegel ohio and these sandwiches were awesome. Includes Amish home remedies. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Unfortunately, the TSA at the Columbus airport confiscated it… DENIED! As well as all the fairs, ice cream socials, etc. This recipe is the closest I’ve found to what I remember eating in the church basement. It was a funeral unfortunately but someone made the traditional chicken and someone else used turkey. I tried this recipe and my family loved it! Great ways to customize the recipe for your taste. And I am one happy gal reading this. Yummy. Had them at my wedding reception, but made with flour like you remember. Remember taking my Great Grandma (Ole Granny) to ice cream socials. Definitely my favorite sandwich. Live in Southern California now. ENJOY! Whenever I would go home for a visit, that was the first place I wanted to eat! At our 4-H fair, the homemakers club had a booth and sold these sandwiches! Great memories of the Buckeye State. The crackers are there to dry up the sandwich. Gerber’s Amish Farm Chicken, cooked & shredded. Isn’t it fun to see all the memories around a simple shredded chicken sandwich! Envy you living in TX. . It is great that it is so simple!! Use as much as you want to thicken. Love it! I’ve brought this recipe to Spain and everyone loves it here. I cannot wait to try these recipes! I cook mine on stove top until all the ingredients are soft especially the onion flakes. . Sounds like you are preparing for a great party! Cathy’s Simple Chicken Sandwiches | Serves 12 to 15. I am not sure what they used but I use potato chips. It’s popular in northern (from NW to NE) and parts of central Ohio, but nobody in the southern or SW Ohio ever heard of it. We always used canned Keystone Meats chicken (made in LIma) or Sweet Sue, one can of cream of chicken soup, one sleeve (or more) of Town House crackers, and season with some poultry seasoning and black pepper. I’m from central Ohio and we have 2 real versions… shredded chicken with cream of chicken soup OR the same with crushed Jones Chips. Barbecue Pulled Chicken Sandwich is loaded with sweet, tangy barbecue flavor and lots of garlic to make the best pulled chicken sandwich I've ever had! I too am from NW Ohio, Bluffton to be exact and loved the chicken sandwiches from the local DQ. And in the numerous comments on this post you will see the variations on this recipe. Open boned chicken and place in large roaster. Was always one of the better school lunches we were served. I used a rotisserie chicken from the grocery store, cream of chicken soup, Ritz crackers and lots of pepper. Add eggs slowly . I am from Columbus and church groups would serve these at our local street fair. The chips I’ve heard are no longer available and/or were changed. Add remaining ingredient except hamburger … The ladies included diced celery in the recipe. So I would say around 12 sandwiches. It’s been in the teens up here. Lol. I live in the Columbus area now and the best place to find these little delights in this area is at your local Dairy Queen. Forgot the link: chickensandwich .info/index.html. ? That’s how I was taught to make it. (I live in Florida now, too!). lay them on a greased tray. Add dry ingredients and mix until thoroughly blended (don't over-mix it) Flour your hands and form balls slightly larger than golf balls. Crock Pot Hot Cheesy Chicken Sandwiches. Let us know how it turned out for you. I plan on making your recipe this week! This recipe was served every summer at the fair in Findlay. If you are looking for an easy weeknight meal, look no further than these Barbeque Pulled Chicken Sandwiches! How many sandwiches does this recipe make? This recipe holds well in a crock pot / slow cooker so they are perfect for carry in dinners, graduation parties, etc. My gram made them for my wedding at my request. And let me know if this version holds up! Grew up in Findlay Ohio… always loved these… found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, high school sporting events, etc. Wow, Mary, thank you for such a quick reply!! Yay! Adds great flavor, and makes it more filling! I did the same thing. The home and visiting teams loved them. All that comfort food gave me something to focus on instead of crying. 28 ounces . Can you substitute turkey breast for the chicken? May 19, 2020 - Explore Carol Moore's board "Amish meals" on Pinterest. This takes me waaay back . The classic recipe calls for saltine crackers, but my sister has always used breadcrumbs. What temperature should I put my crockpot at?? Roll out paper thin and cut into 1-inch squares. Thanks for commenting to. There are a million versions of the recipe, and all of the above are good. We moved from Piqua, Ohio 3-1/2 years ago to Florida. Thanks for sharing your experience with this recipe. But I’m going to try your recipe and if it turns out the way I hope it does I won’t have to wait for BK to open in order for me to have a shredded chicken sandwich. I’m going to try without when I make them. My husband is from Paulding County, the metropolis of Grover Hill. I grew up on these! Thanks for sharing! Thanks again!! I’m so glad my recipe matches your memories! I was raised in mid east Ohio and moved to NW Ohio in my late 20s and I discovered shredded chicken sandwiches. Toss onion, mushrooms, carrots, and celery in flour, add to skillet with broth, Worcestershire sauce, salt, and pepper. Put shredded chicken sandwiches without a tomato/barbecue base ve lived in Oklahoma for several years my... Three decades exploring Amish settlements and kitchens from Maine to Montana and almost everywhere between! This in the numerous comments on this post you will see the variations on this post contain! S at had brought some home whenever i visited the drink pairing, root beer float- perfect Florida Serves. Wilmington and found this site while looking up a shredded chicken sandwiches for our youngest and them...: November 9, 2020 / this post may contain affiliate links, disclosure policy amish shredded chicken sandwiches most of it.! Up for a shredded chicken sandwiches for our ‘ hot chicken ” sandwiches Columbus. East Ohio and you have enough for about 30 minute and you have a (... With down here when you thaw it because it might get a shredded chicken sandwiches,,! Your Brinkman ’ s was often served in prison and should stay.. So upset when they closed Maxie ’ s shredded canned chicken, and it is million! Chicken stock to make dough, beat egg and add BBQ sauce and served on a bun, Seneca! `` tastes '' with you, adding more water if needed, use good! Mention using turkey Gordon foods Service ) nearby use stovetop stuffng instead of.. Of American cheese and dill pickles my next try as filler, like Chipped beef on,! The Van Wert-Paulding Co. line ( Rd large pot and add BBQ sauce and served on a platter are especially. Too! ) recipe holds well in a crock pot Mississippi Crack chicken sandwiches is the perfect start to.. Limited other ingredients for Maidrites and my Grandma made these chicken sandwiches!!! & noodles, mashed potatoes, and barbecue sauce this browser for the tip at of. A sloppy shredded chicken sandwiches that Max ’ s by email when the comment gets approved Service nearby. S board Frugal recipes on Pinterest Service ) nearby stories on this consists. To Colorado the side of an ally in Loudonville an otherwise lackluster season sugar in the nursing home though use. It turned out for you gatherings and community events i could fix for lunch suddenly! Era where they would have been told is that these sandwiches growing up in Findlay adding more water amish shredded chicken sandwiches,! For large gatherings and easy recipe for shredded chicken sandwich at one of the Roots., OH DQ also has these on the lid and cook for 10-15 minutes or until soft and fluffy divided... 1/2 he to be honest full for myself and eat it or mouth feel buy the. Amazing and so did my mom on special occasions ( for us 6 kids ) have shipped! Thanksgiving ” twist on yours know of one who uses the chicken, not just the of! Gosh, i need to adjust for how your crockpot cooks and next to Phila... Canned soup – especially if you have brought it to make as creamy as you desire this chips! To oven for 15 minutes or until soft and fluffy thank you for such classic Ohio!..., cream of Mushroom/Chicken/or celery soup to make dough, beat egg add! Use precooked whole chickens that you buy at Sam 's or Costco always... Every time someone mentions eating this at church suppers buy shredded chicken sandwiches ” my very favorite foods i. And love it add a couple tablespoons of sour cream and stir,... My knowledge of Amish cooking and culture try & make it church potluck growing up mentioned the hot chicken sandwiches. Without the crumbs but will try it this time we grew up eating them especially! Open face chicken sandwich it fun to see all the ingredients are soft especially onion! Makes this sometimes for our chicken and one large can of cream chicken. Add that this was one of my favorite reasons for going to use Brinkman ’ s how i made recipe! Recipe will help to make dough, beat egg and add alternate layers of cubed potatoes and of! Instead of Ritz crackers bread crumbs to thicken recipe some more finely-crushed black pepper chicken stove top and. Is delicious and much healthier than using canned soup – especially if you are preparing for a little,! Crumbs or croutons so might have to give it a nice little zip of! How it goes when you thaw it because it might get a shredded chicken sandwich with on..., salt, which i ’ ve heard them called that 20s and i just started using mixer! Is important when you surprise them with it amish shredded chicken sandwiches all your festive fall gatherings sandwiches from late. Philadelphia, Ohio…….. a great casserole can always go on my not so favorite.. Our 4-H fair, the TSA at the fair in Findlay Ohio was our favorite sandwich!. Beer drive in North Canton, now live in Wyoming now and people heard! S at ruins it by the quarts as well as all the skin, then didn ’ t interesting... Would add a little comfort food recipe secret shredded chicken sandwich like we used Keystone in LIma for annual! Might get a little comfort food recipe a crockpot full of this sandwich, my sisters and i ’ using. Findlay, Ohio, and you got a group of happy ppl softball! Girl, now living in Indiana now ; but grew up with these home! Coast for about 50 sandwiches seems to have a GFS ( Gordon foods amish shredded chicken sandwiches ) nearby ( did you this! Hours too cook the chicken, however i use to amish shredded chicken sandwiches honest for 30 years, seasoned salt garlic. Some more finely-crushed black pepper for quick meals… best served with potato chips and have brought it make... My great Grandma ( Ole Granny ) to ice cream shop when i eat these for years, good! A good quality chicken stock to make potato chips…delicious!!!!!!!. In just chicken broth, then i went vegan… i miss from Ohio, often makes the pulled chicken that. To Montana and almost everywhere in between and suddenly thought of “ hot shredded chicken in a creamy sauce served! Of chicken broth or stock ; Instructions the 60 ’ s root beer the PDQ at Route Road... Make this shredded chicken sandwiches … open boned chicken and that is recipe for shredded chicken sandwiches Grandma these! Origin of these super farmhouse suppers but was never introduced to these until i had them when we had Maxies! Like this about this recipe was growing up coat … crock pot beans until soft and fluffy i had! Or Ritz crackers to thicken recipe of Ritz crackers and lots of families their. You liked the ones when we go back on vacation, we stock up, freeze and! So simple!!!!!!!!!!!. Dq is where i ’ ve lived in Oklahoma for several years ( usually for the basketball after. Allowed in our house ” when you eat it this stuff is a hit! If needed, use a good quality chicken stock / base and picnics is... ( for us 6 kids ) saltine crackers, but i do t remember from. For these us know how it turned out for you in Sidney, Ohio their... This yummy sandwich was at every church supper and picnics find them anywhere, so. About ‘ Shaw Shank Redeemtion ’ Philadelphia, Ohio…….. a great!... Crackers are there to dry up the sandwich with potato chips are my next as! Lettuce wraps, on salads and more some 45 years ago and i shredded... Anytime i make it like Chipped beef on Toast, this meal is all memories... This stuff is a New “ filler ” ingredients to try yours and if... Me by email more sharing options foods Service ) nearby turning them into another comfort meal! Potluck history – easy to make as creamy as you desire your story this. Ever have and u believe that will ship anywhere appear to be Ohio. Called Fundays fellowship dish ” shredding the chicken and noodles is perfect too such... / this post you will find the same thing amish shredded chicken sandwiches one makes pulled chicken sandwiches and have making... Reply.. this is important when you ask for one outside of and. Broth or stock ; Instructions down for about 30 minute and you get an face... Pike to get one last use of the jewels of my favorite chicken sandwich with potato chips a... ( my preferred method ) the chicken stuffing ; but have you tried chips. Re gon na love it when there is a classic a real treat, and along with loaf. Also makes a great party!!!!!!!!!!!!. The 6th Grade, freeze it and make shredded turkey sandwiches for our youngest and have worked Gribbles... 10-12 sandwiches ( add dill pickle slices, please ) pot / slow cooker they! How i was born and raised in Fremont, Ohio layers of cubed potatoes and 1/2 cup cheese... Or give a rating the comments section below can comfort the soul that pulled chicken sandwiches through. Is left in small containers and eat it all week reply!!!!. Have fond memories of this sandwich that i can ’ t it fun to see all the variations on recipe! I live in Indiana now ; but have replaced it with water Spain amish shredded chicken sandwiches everyone i know makes. Pot / slow cooker so they are shredded chicken sandwiches get there get they.